Latest news, updates, and insights from Rate My Supervisor
I was sitting in a cramped booth at a dive bar near campus when the television flickered to a news segment about Jill Biden's Ed.D. The table erupted. In academia, the "Doctor" title is often the only thing we actually own — so of course we're territorial about it. But after five years of watching this system operate, I think we're asking completely the wrong question.
March is Regalia Season. The price tag for a custom PhD Regalia can easily top $1,000 — a painful hit for someone living on a stipend. But as I watched a colleague try on her robes in the breakroom, we both realized the same thing: the most expensive piece of regalia isn't the $900 silk-blend gown. It's the signature from your PI that actually allows you to wear it.
I was sitting in a cramped, fluorescent-lit office, staring at a $2,800 rent invoice due in three days. The F-1 clock was ticking in the background, as it always does when your legal status is tied to a single institution. Beside me, a first-year student was vibrating with excitement about his Direct PhD offer. He saw a shortcut. I saw a high-stakes gamble with no safety net.
Every morning at 8:30 AM, Lukas walked into the windowless basement lab and said a bright "Guten Morgen." He looked people in the eye. He meant it. By month six, the greetings were quieter. By month eight, he was gone. This is a story about what happens to the person in the lab who still tries to be human — and what the rest of us owe them.
I still remember the exact moment, early in my first year, when I printed out a potential PI's Google Scholar profile. His h-index was 85. Those numbers looked like a golden ticket. What the metrics didn't show was the three students who had mastered out in the last eighteen months...
It's 11:30 PM on a Sunday when your advisor emails asking why those data points haven't been uploaded yet. You spent ten hours in the lab, but for a micromanager, if they didn't see it happening in real-time, it didn't happen. Here's how to survive—and thrive.